At one of my first fundraising jobs, I sat down and was told I needed to write our donor newsletter. That was it. That was the guidance. We sent it through a clunky tool, and I couldn't figure out how to format the header image so it wasn't all pixelated. My only instructions were, "Write a donor newsletter."
I'm pretty sure that newsletter was long, verbose, and all over the place. Luckily, I don't think any of us will ever find it, so I never have to revisit it. It would be like cracking open a childhood diary to reread the entries where I professed my first love. Nope. Let's not go there.
I'd bet that's how a lot of us started. Somebody said "can you write some donor emails?" and that was the whole training.
Those cringe-worthy early emails are where it starts. This post is about getting good at something nobody taught you, what you've got to work with along the way, and why people thrown into the deep end often turn into the stronger storytellers.
Nobody budgeted for this
Email is how most of us talk to our donors. It's the main line for a lot of organizations, carrying updates, appeals, thank-yous, and invitations. And writing it is almost always an afterthought, something that gets done at 4pm on a Tuesday between a grant report and a board packet.
Compare that to how it works anywhere else. Most companies have a marketing department, or they hire an agency, to write their emails. My husband used to run a 13-person team, and a big part of what they did all day was write good emails. Thirteen people. Now picture your development coordinator, who is also doing data entry, event logistics, and whatever landed in their inbox under "other duties as assigned," trying to get an appeal out the door with no guidance at all.
It's no wonder this feels overwhelming. We're diving way into the deep end when we barely know how to swim.
The deep end has assets
Good news: you don't have to invent this from scratch. Whole industries do email marketing for a living, and they've already figured out a lot of what works.
Best practices exist for a reason. They aren't there for funsies. They come from people who send emails for a living and have watched what works and what flops. Browse a gallery like Really Good Emails and you'll see what a good email looks like next to the wall of text most of us wrote in our early days.
I think of it like art. Before you can be a modern artist, you learn to draw. You master the basics so that when you break the rules, you're breaking them on purpose.
The basics aren't mysterious. A real person's name as the sender. A short, honest subject line. Preview text that isn't left on the default. An opening line that acknowledges your relationship to the reader. A short body, written at about a sixth-grade reading level. One specific ask, one button, and a P.S. (people love a PS).
If you want one thing to steal, steal this: think of a campaign as one story told in five moments. You warm people up with no hard ask, make the ask early and clearly on launch day, show progress in a reminder, share a fresh short story in a mid-campaign update, and finish with a real deadline and a real number. Same story, a different job for each email.
Fundraising emails are where all of this matters most, because the stakes feel highest and the guidance is thinnest. We put together a quick guide for exactly those emails, and you'll find it at the end of this post.
Do what you have capacity for
Once you start reading about email best practices, the advice piles up fast. A/B test your subject lines. Segment into twelve audiences. Automate every touchpoint. Some of it is great, and none of it is required.
So much of what I've learned about nonprofit work comes back to this: do what you have capacity for now, not what you wish you had capacity for. If you have time to write one good email and send it to your whole list, write the one good email. Testing can wait. Plenty of excellent fundraising happens without a single split test.
What the deep end teaches you
Being thrown in without a script means nobody handed you the voice, so you get to find your own. I think that's where the best emails come from.
Be someone. So many nonprofits shy away from having a personality, like we're going to scare our donors off. The result is that every appeal and update sounds like everyone else's. This is my own personal observation, as well as my personal wish: I want to hear from you. Not generic acme corporation.
Be clear about who you are. Having a personality still means telling me who you are. I once got a Giving Tuesday email from an organization whose branding didn't remind me who they were, whose name I didn't recognize, and which gave no hint of my relationship to them. Had I volunteered? Attended an event? Been added to a list at a conference? I was too busy to play detective, so I deleted it. If I have to do detective work to figure out why you're in my inbox, I'm not going to donate. Tell me who you are, how I know you, what you need, and why it matters now.
Tell stories that aren't the same sob story. You know the one. We've all read it a hundred times. If your story sounds interchangeable with another organization's, find the detail that only you have. (Our post on Your Organization Evolved. Has Your Fundraising? goes deeper on refreshing the language you've been using on repeat.)
Throw in the unexpected photo. An email shouldn't feel like a check-writing ceremony. A surprising, human image tells your reader there's a person behind this.
That's what the deep end gives you. Writing emails with no training makes you pay attention to what real people respond to, which is most of what storytelling is. People who learn by doing often end up better communicators than people who learned from a template, because they had to notice what lands.
We can only learn this from each other
This part is bigger than email.
None of this works unless you can admit you don't know something, and nobody is naturally good at that. We spend a lot of energy in this sector performing competence for funders, for boards, for each other. Meanwhile the person two organizations over, who could save you an hour, is pretending they have it figured out too.
We learn from our peers by asking for help, reading each other's emails, swapping drafts, and saying "I wrote this and I'm not sure it works" out loud. That's vulnerable, and it's also how we build the training the sector never gave us. If the sector isn't going to train people before handing them donor communications, we can at least get in the habit of training each other.
Being generous with what we have matters just as much as being honest about what we don't. Share the email that got a great response. Share the one that bombed. Both are useful.
You're allowed to be a beginner
If you're the accidental email writer at your organization, the one who got handed this and figured it out as you went: you're not behind. Nobody ever showed you.
Try this week: swap two emails with a peer at another organization, ideally two you read and enjoyed instead of two you wrote. Notice what made you open them and what made you keep reading. Then steal one thing.
Good enough and sent beats perfect and never. You can cringe at it later. I still do.
We put together a short guide for the fundraising side of all this: The Fundraising Email Guide for Accidental Email Writers. It walks through the parts of a fundraising email, includes ethical storytelling questions to run before you send, and ends with a one-page checklist you can use as a litmus test.